Skip to content
Click to Call Send us a Text
Ben Mason Insurance Agency LLC

188 Blalock Rd
Boiling Springs, SC 29316

Get Directions

Insurance Blog

South Carolina’s 51% Fault Rule and Your Auto Claim

After a crash on I-85 or a road near Lake Blalock, the question of who was at fault shapes almost everything that follows. South Carolina doesn’t use an all-or-nothing rule. Instead, it divides responsibility by percentage, with one important cutoff that every driver should understand.

How South Carolina’s Fault Rule Works

Since the South Carolina Supreme Court’s 1991 decision in Nelson v. Concrete Supply Co., the state has followed a modified comparative negligence rule. An injured person can recover damages as long as their share of fault isn’t greater than the other party’s, and those damages are reduced by their own percentage.

Your Share of Fault What Generally Happens
0% You may recover your full damages from the at-fault party
20% Your recovery is generally reduced by 20%
50% You may still recover, reduced by half
51% or more You’re generally barred from recovering damages from the other party

Your Questions, Answered

Who decides the percentages?

Insurers make their own assessments during a claim, and if a case goes to court, a judge or jury decides. Police reports and photos often play a big role.

Can I still be responsible for the other driver’s damages?

Yes. If you share fault, your liability coverage may respond to the other driver’s claim against you.

How does my own coverage help?

Collision coverage can repair your car regardless of fault, subject to your deductible. Medical payments coverage helps with injury costs no matter who caused the crash, and uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage can step in when the at-fault driver lacks enough insurance.

Protecting Your Side of the Story

  • Avoid admitting fault at the scene
  • Photograph vehicles, road conditions, and traffic signals
  • Collect witness names and contact information
  • Request a copy of the police report

Legal deadlines apply to injury claims, so talk with a South Carolina attorney if you’re hurt.

Our post on collision vs. comprehensive coverage explains another key distinction. Ben Mason Insurance Agency in Boiling Springs, SC can review your auto insurance. Drivers across Boiling Springs, SC and Spartanburg County can reach out to Ben Mason Insurance Agency anytime.

Partner Carriers

  • American Integrity
  • American Modern
  • Assurance America
  • Foremost
  • National General
  • Nationwide
  • Progressive
  • Travelers